A forum for open discussion on communities and local government policy.

Commission on the role of local councillors

Welcome to our forum. We’ve had a terrific response so far and the comments we have received confirm for me how passionately people feel about the role councillors play on behalf of the communities they represent. Please keep your comments coming.

Our question this month is ‘what do councillors need to enable them to perform their role effectively?’

It’s a good time to ask this question. Local elections have just taken place in many parts of the country and newly elected councillors are taking their first steps in the role. What support do they need and what are they receiving? If you are one of them, tell us about your early experiences of life as an elected member. How is your work load? Are you managing the balance between your responsibilities and other commitments to work or family life? Is it as you expected, or have there been any surprises?

We’d like to hear too from people who have been councillors in the past or who are now continuing in the role: how have your skills been developed and where do you find the support you need? Then there are those of you who work with councillors, or who come into contact with them in a variety of ways. What do you need from elected members and do you find they have the skills and
expertise you’d expect? How can they be helped more to help you?

It’s a fascinating area and I’m sure you’ll have lots to say, so please sign up to the forum and let us have your views.

Thank you for taking part.

Dr Jane Roberts DBE
Chair

Support for Councillors

Posted by Rob Mitchell on 28/06/2007 - 16:23

Following discussion with elected Members with the Association of North East Councils, the following points are made
• Practical and administrative support from within councils on a range of things including letter writing would be helpful as it would free councillors’ time up for ward and other matters;
• Mentoring schemes that are developed as part of Members’ own personal development plans would be a valuable support, especially for new elected Members;
• Mentoring from colleagues from another authority, possibly from a different type of authority, would be useful, e.g. mentoring of a District Councillor by a Councillor from a Unitary for example;
• Personal development plans for new and longer-serving Councillors should be introduced widely to help Members fully understand the skills required to undertake their role. Such plans need to have a great deal of flexibility to accommodate Members’ own preferences for learning and to accommodate Members’ other pressures: work-life balance;
• Designated Members Support Officers were seen as good practice, but not all councils had them. It was noted that Members also needed support from officers across councils’ service departments in order to solve ward problems – awareness raising with officers would therefore be useful;
A clear explanation of the role of Members, including their roles on external bodies (e.g. Trustees), was seen as vital. An understanding of the legal implications of becoming a trustee was felt to be an essential part of that as Members are often unaware of potential ramifications of decisions they may be party to as a trustee. A national indemnity scheme for trustees would be helpful;

Question Closed

Posted by Emma Hagan on 18/06/2007 - 16:16

Many thanks to everyone who has contributed to the forum so far. This question has now closed and we will be posting a new one shortly.

Your answers will be considered by the Commission as part of its evidence gathering process. It is also commissioning a programme of social research, seeking expert advice and arranging a series of events for people to attend around the country.

Further responses to ‘what do councillors need to enable them to perform their role effectively?’ will not be shown on the forum but they can be sent here

We look forward to your responses to our new question which will be posted tomorrow.

Thanks again

Emma

New question

Posted by Emma Hagan on 15/06/2007 - 15:54

Thanks to all of you for your responses so far, they are valued contributions.

Our question will be changing shortly so please tell us what you think councillors need to enable them to perform their role effectively before Tuesday 19th May.

It’s interesting to hear Sandra’s experiences as she gets to grips with her new role and we are keen to hear from other new councillors as well as those of you with more experience. We also want to hear views from people who work and come in to contact with councillors, so please keep those responses coming!

what do councillors need to enable them to perform their role

Posted by Terry Falcao on 10/06/2007 - 19:05

Terry Falcao

A council set up that is sympathetic to working people.

The profiles of some (rural) councils are largely of retired and elderly councillors. There are exceptions with those who own their own businesses. This means in practice that councillors are not representative of the majority of their constituents, and may be disadvantaged in terms of their understanding and connection to young people.

Councillors require legislation that supports and enables them to participate fully in local government. Absence from work should be made easier and even expected. Businesses should see some return on their contirbution to local Government. This would be epecially useful to attract highly skilled individuals to commit themselves to council work. The alternatives are bleak in that unrepresentative chambers will persist and the current level of apathy towards local elections are likely to increase and render them pointless and void.

Relationship between representative and participatory democracy

Posted by Ms Geeta Patel on 01/06/2007 - 12:20

It is important that councillors develop their understanding of participatory forms of democracy alongside their representative role and work with local people to champion new forms of community consultations and feedback.

what do councillors need to enable them to perform their role?

Posted by PaullR on 21/05/2007 - 08:05

Councillors need a clear view of who they represent, and on what basis they carry out their role.

At ward level my experience is that constituents and local businesses are not interested in the political aspirations or associations of a Councillor, but need to be certain that the local community as a whole is being actively supported and engaged

Councillors must use their unique position to create strong working relationships with officers to ensure that they can get quickly to the heart of a matter that residents would find intractable.

Active support from officers is readily available for councillors who work at building those relationships based on mutual respect. Similar levels of engagement with other agencies (health, police, LSC etc are also attainable by active engagement in cross authority committees, scrutiny panels)

Tact, local knowledge, transparent concern for any legitimate issue (even if you personally disagree with it) and the time to meet residents when and where it suits them.

What do councillors need?

Posted by David Lawrence on 16/05/2007 - 07:57

RECOGNITION

Councillors divide into groups. Those who are creating a job for themselves and integrate with the officers. Those who wish to play a service role but are limited in experience or training to their local environment.
However it is the third group that could do more. They have retired from National or International affairs, are in some cases more intelligent, more experienced and better qualified than the officers.
This group of non executive directors is often ignored by the current system.
It is because they have more challenge to offer that they are sidelined in these days when hype is more significant than fact.

David Lawrence

What do new councillors need

Posted by Sandra Semple on 10/05/2007 - 09:08

May I also add that we need appropriate training close to home for new councillors.

We received a pack that showed that if we wanted to do a 1 day course we would need to travel nearly 40 miles away (with no public transport). Several of us don't have access to cars and most of us can't spare the extra 2-3 hours of travelling time and time away from family committments.

It should be mandatory for each district council to offer appropriate training to their local town and parish councillors.

What do councillors need to perform their roles

Posted by Sandra Semple on 08/05/2007 - 20:55

I am a totally new councillor (and, to make things worse, I was elected Mayor for the year at our first meeting!).

What would have helped me this evening:

A list of all the committees that councillors have to be on with minimum/maximum numbers on it and a note of who sat on each committee last year.

A copy of the current budget and last year's income and expenditure.

A list of all the outside organisations' meetings that councillors attend in their capacity as councillor with some notes on exactly what each of the organisations does and why it is felt necessary that councillors should be on them (for example, we have 2 traffic committees, 2 police committees - do we need to be on all 4 or 1, 2 3 or none.

A good Town Clerk!

What skills do Councillors need (Backbenchers take note...)

Posted by PAULCORAZZO on 08/05/2007 - 16:57

Having been a backbench councillor for the last four years and now back again for the next four, I have learned three things that help perform the role effectively and I want to share with others:

1. Keep consituents regularly informed of what you do, e.g. e-mail, blog, newsletters

2. Read the paperwork you need to read and dispose of everything else immediately ( I know councillors who have garages full of council papers dating back 30 years...) BIN IT!

3. Speak to councillors of other parties and officers - together aims can be achieved, despite idealogical differences.

1
Next page
Last page